Citation:
Cronin, Dorren. (2011). The
trouble with chickens. New York: HarperCollins
Children’s Books.
Summary:
Jonathan Joseph Tully (J. J.) thought that he had a relaxing retirement
from his days as a specially trained search-and-rescue job to look forward to.
Unfortunately, J. J. realized that peace and relaxation were not in the cards
for him, the moment that Millicent—the crazy chicken from the yard—approached him
for help on a case. Two of her four little chicks are missing, and she needs
his help. Part of the story is told from the point of view of Vince, the inside
dog who is unable to get through his doggie door leading outside thanks to his
cone of shame. He is the very sinister creature that has masterminded this dastardly
deed. Or is he…?
Impressions:
Although written for elementary age children, the mature voice and dry
wit of J. J. Tully make this book an enjoyable read for just about any age.
Students stand to learn a bit about the search-and-rescue process that trained
dogs go through from this book. The illustrations are a terrific addition to
this book, and do an excellent job of depicting the quirkiness of Millicent and
her idiosyncratic baby chicks. It’s a great beginning chapter book for students
transitioning into longer texts.
Usage in a Library:
I specifically remember sniffer dogs visiting our elementary school for
special programs once a year. This book could be paired with a visit from the
local police department, and a safety lesson. It would also make for a great
book to pair with animal books or mysteries in a book talk. You might also
consider pairing this with a search and rescue hunt in the library – the students
can help identify and find lost books in conjunction with a Dewey Decimal
System lesson.
Review:
Retirement suits J. J. Tully, former search-and-rescue dog, just fine,
until his quiet life in the country is rudely disrupted by a chicken.
Millicent, whom Tully dubs “Moosh,” is an unhappy hen because she’s missing two
of her four fluffy chickes. Tully begrudgingly takes the case, en rout coming
head to head with Vincent, the household’s cantankerous indoor dog, and with
the fact that the adorable peeping chicks conceal cunning behind their innocent
appearance. This is noir so lighthearted that it’s barely pale gray, and it’s
as cartoonishly councy (slapstick involving Vincent’s anti-gnawing Elizabethan
collar and the dog door, for instance) as it is hardboiled in phraseology (“She
reminded me of a three-inch splinter I’d had once—it bothered me, and I was in
a much better mood once it was gone”). The plot’s a little labyrinthine, but
this is a story to read for style rather than sense, and the every-changing
relationship between Tully and his poultry clients (including some classic
double-crossing) is rewardingly goofy and, eventually, affectionate. Big print,
short chapters, and unabashedly comedic illustrations (bespectacles chick nerd
Sugar is the star comedienne) aim the book squarely at readers between Cazet’s
Minnie and Moo (Mnnie and Moo Go to the Moon, BCCB 9/98, etc.) and Hale’s Chet
Gecko (The Chameleon Wore Chartreuse, BCCB 6/00, etc.).
Review Citation:
Stevenson, D. (2011). The trouble with
chickens. Bulletin of the Center for
Children's Books, 64(7), 325.